B2B Customer Intelligence Series - Introduction

My job title and primary focus is Data Governance, however the data I spend the most time managing is B2B data. As a former consultant, I constantly find myself suggesting new applications to drive Sales and Marketing programs. Sometimes it’s as basic as dipping into database reserves to find new prospects, but often my extracurricular projects are pure Customer Intelligence, also referred to as CI. Customer Intelligence can cover a lot of ground, so let me define it.

Customer Intelligence is the intersection of Sales, Marketing, and Analytics that helps present the best customers and prospects to inform company strategy and tactical approach.

Customer Intelligence work manifests itself as Analytic projects including predictive modeling, cross-functional leads programs, and Sales and Marketing strategy projects. In most companies I’ve worked with, Customer Intelligence is distributed across several functions and that group collectively defines the companies Customer Relationship approach. In others a central group focuses on Customer Intelligence and coordinates the distribution of related information to drive strategy.

Other companies have no Customer Intelligence. They are Customer Ignorant. In that case, the Sales and Marketing teams approach customers based on generic approaches and anecdotal history of which customers are the “best”. With good products and excellent customer service, this approach can work. However, over time it will open the door for competitors to take over and dominate the market.

Here are a few thoughts for the upcoming series. The plan is for each of these topics to be developed as an entire post over the next few weeks. If you have other suggestions, please comment on the post or tweet a reply to @markgoloboy.

1) Customer Intelligence Flexibility

No matter how successful it is, every sales strategy will be retired someday. It may be next week. It may be next year. But be sure, the target will be set somewhere other than it is today. How do you build a Customer Intelligence strategy that allows your organization to stay agile?

2) Aligning Against the Opportunity

Once properly implemented your Customer Intelligence approach should become an integral part of the sales reps’ day. How do you integrate the information with your existing processes and systems to align against the opportunity?

3) Direct Marketing Impact on Sales

Customer Intelligence can help define a set of high value prospects that deliver return on Marketing investment. Determining which factors influence purchasing requires advanced analytics. What’s the best way to develop analytic models and measure whether they predict a prospect’s likelihood to become a customer?

4) Defining Lifetime Value

Determining Lifetime Value (LTV) of a customer and potential LTV of a prospect can align Sales, Marketing and Product goals with corporate strategy. However, LTV analysis requires that your product and sales data has been collected consistently for your company’s history. How do you develop and use LTV to drive product direction and Sales and Marketing focus?

Data Governance for the Executive Level

You’ve done your work. You understand the issues. This is your one chance, so it better be smooth.

My previous blog posts have focused on Lightweight Data Governance for the most part. I’ve sprinkled in some more fomal theory that I’ve learned from the experienced pros, but for the most part I’m writing about my own experience with Data Governance. If I sat here and told you the best way to manage a mature interdepartmental Data Governance practice, you’d call B.S. And you’d be justified in doing so.

With that backdrop, I’m going to begin to describe the transition from Lightweight to Formal practice. I don’t yet know where I’ll end up, but along the way I’ll try to help others with their journey. At some point you will find the limit of project based, department level Data Governance. Whether it’s funding for resources and tools, or interdepartmental coordination, you will need to present Data Governace to a room full of executives.

Do you have a mature presentation ready at a moments notice?

You never know when you’re going to be asked to present. Your boss may say something in a meeting and the next day you get your opportunity. You should create a short 3 or 4 slide presentation that quickly justifies the work your team does. It should be provocative, show the problems and your solutions to them, and clearly demonstrate the value your team represents to the company.

The slides should include:

1. Your Company’s Problem and how Data Governance can solve it
2. Your Current Work Plan, which should be High Level and written in business terms
3. Your roadmap for the next 12 - 24 months
4. Challenges (funding, resources, roadblocks) and your solution to them

Do you have sponsors who can describe your value?

If you are the only one who believes your work is necessary, then it’s not. You must build relationships with the teams you work with, and build credibility with their management over time. If you were called into a meeting right now, which three executives one or two levels above you would you invite? Who would be invited by the organizer. They should understand how your work benefits them, and be willing to stand up for you.

Get right to the point.

Why do the executives need to spend this 30 or 60 minutes listening to your presentation? Think about it from their perspective. They have much better things to work on than this, right? Tell them why it matters up front. Make it about revenue potential, solutions to business (not data or technology) problems, or cost savings. That’s the way an executive thinks. You can also talk about control, compliance, and the corporate maturity that your work representes. But, trust me, focus on the dollars and business problems first.

How can Data Governance increase revenue?

This one is especially important during this terrible economy. What’s your company’s #1 goal this year? Sales. Nothing else matters if there’s no money coming in the door. How can Data Governance help the Sales team?

1. Clean up customer data so the reps know what to focus on. This will require improved systems, better processes for reps, Finance / Order Administration, Customer Service, and anyone else who touches customer data. That interdepartmental coordination requires Data Governance to understand the issues caused by poor data quality.
2. Improving the data will remove inneficient admin tasks from your Sales Rep’s day, allowing them to focus on selling more. If the Rep needs to sift through old prospects that will never purchase to find the hidden gems, they are not working efficiently. Data Governance should develop the processes to maintain the Sales reps portfolio systematically so they have fresh data to work with. Obviously, this is more important as your Sales organization and customer base grows. If you have 100s or even 1000s of customers, you can probably ignore this one.
3. Allow management to focus on the issue, and not the noise. Every time a Sales rep sees a bad row of data, they either move on, cringe and move on, or scream about it. The ones who move on quickly make the most money. The ones who scream are looking for excuses not to sell. They will complain to their management, who will invariably complain to those responsible for the data. Is that you? By removing the excuse that the data is bad, management can focus on the real issues of Sales productivity.

What business problem problem are you solving?

I think the fun part of Data Governance is that it allows you to help resolve longstanding business problems and answer tough questions. If that’s the result of your early data governance work, you’ll get funding to do more. What is the direct business impact caused by inconsistent, incorrect, or misleading data permeating your organization? Who screams about it in meetings? Go ask them how you can help. When you understand their business problem you will know where to start.

Lastly, how can it reduce costs?

The most important part of that question is “Lastly.” Everyone else starts there, but I think it’s the hardest to sell to your management. A revenue or business problem based justication is more strategic than a cost savings plan. Anyone can save costs. Cutting resources or choosing different tools is easy. Look around. Your management has done it repeatedly this year.

CRM Marketing Strategy To Drive Sales Revenue

For the purpose of this post, I’m defining Marketing Strategy to mean the analytics that complement the work done by the Database / CRM Marketing team and the influence that those analytics can have on Sales and Marketing programs. This article isn’t about Brand, Creative, or Media Purchase. It’s also not about Social Media, SEM or SEO. Just to be clear, I’m writing about using Data, Technology, & Analytics to reach out to customers and prospects, improve program results and drive revenue. Generally my recommendations are specific to Email Marketing, but may also be applied to Direct Mail or TeleMarketing.

Marketing Strategy should be the heading under which your company defines it’s analytically based sales programs. But you don’t need a fully developed internal analytics shop to be strategic. In fact, that isn’t the first step at all. First, focus on your data. It doesn’t matter how good your analysts are, they won’t be effective or efficient if you give them low quality data to work with.

So, let’s begin with the data. The following three areas of Marketing Strategy rely on Data Governance, so for my opinions there read up on Lightweight Data Governance.

Opportunity Analysis

If your data isn’t clean, you can’t get a feel for how well you are doing. For instance, duplicates in your data when analyzed in aggregate cause double-counting within buckets, double-counting across buckets, and general noise that diminishes the value of analytics and modeling. If you have the same company listed as both a customer and a prospect, and they both fall in the same industry or geography, your analytics driven programs will fail.

The solution is to develop a source system down approach to gathering data for your Marketing Strategy work. If you collect the data with reporting and analysis in mind, downstream processes will benefit. So work with your Sales, Service and Finance teams. It will take them an extra few seconds to correct the problem. Every customer facing employee should spend a few seconds each time they speak with a customer to ask, “Is our contact information for you still correct?” That change, which may require a culture shift that starts with the executive team, will dramatically improve program results.

Targeting and Personalization

Do you use Marketing Strategy and leverage data to drive campaign results? Test and Learn is a sneaky term for Marketing Strategy. It sounds less expensive, so use it.

Your content should be specific to your target’s business problem. It should be tailored to their purchase history, or lack thereof, and include next (or first) best product or cross-sell specific messaging. You should personalize the email to the targets name, title, company name, and other fields in your CRM system. If you have analyzed the lift generated by personalized vs. non-personalized messaging, you understand the need to target your emails. 

When you segment targets and personalize the subject line and body content of your emails, your open and click-through rates will increase significantly. Also, your opt-out rates will go down. The quality of these key fields must be monitored and improved to take advantage of that lift.

Compliance and Customer Interaction

If you are not familiar with CAN-SPAM, read my take on your responsibilities as an email marketer. You are required by law to do a great job at managing email opt-outs and confirming that your business is transparently represented in your email marketing. Even forgetting about email compliance, you should still consider the customer impact of bad marketing. “Mark Goloboy or Current Resident” = Trash Can. Trash Can = Poor return on direct mail spend. Read: Not enough revenue to justify your program.

So how do you mature your processes quickly to take advantage of the potential sales impact of Marketing Strategy? You must develop quality processes that remove bounced emails from your lists and opt-out all instances of an email address when requested. You also need to be sure your sales reps are honoring your opt-outs. Lastly, you must review your data for patterns of Sales or Service rep entered garbage. What’s the most frequently occurring word in the First Name field of your contact records? I bet it’s not “John.”

Data Acquisition

Whether you are in B2C or B2B Marketing, there is value in purchasing reference data for your existing customers, and lead data for prospecting. How much value is there? You need to test purchases from different vendors to determine that. There’s no other way. Buy a small list. Or better, ask a list vendor for a free list to test. They aren’t selling a lot now. Take advantage! Then predict ROI by scaling the results and associated spend across your whole universe of customer and prospect data.

You can also measure the impact of cleaning, de-duplicating and referencing your data to a standard set by testing those processes against a statistically significant sample of your customer data. Again, you may be able to get some of these services for free by getting into a competitive sales situation. Your prospects ask you for this, right? Mastering this customer data requires assistance and cooperation from Sales, Marketing, Customer Service and Technology, which means Data Governance.

KQIs (Key Quality Indicators) To Measure Data Quality

At the recent MIT Information Quality Industry Symposium, the hot topic was measuring the impact of data quality programs. In a bad economy, it makes perfect sense. If your company is cutting programs, you need to justify your data quality initiatives, or they too will be cut. My favorite presentation on the topic was from Delphine Clement, whose topic was the, “Cost of Non Quality Data.” I thought that was an interesting way to look at it, and she presented a very mature view of Data Management. Delphine credited sessions from previous MIT Information Quality Symposiums with some of the underlying theory. I’m sure there are others to credit as well, and if you know the history please comment.

Delphine reports on the Key Quality Indicators (KQIs) that matter the most to her business partners. She has taught the business community that KQIs are needed to build confidence in the KPIs. I like that the KQI approach mirrors the KPIs (in naming and level of importance), and that they are presented as a complementary report. Think of this as the metadata for the KPIs. That’s the way I rationalized it.

KQIs would make sense to any Data Quality lead, but it might not to a VP of Marketing or VP of Sales. It’s not their job to care how we do ours. So how do you bridge the gap with the executive KPI users? You must understand their needs, and show them that the KQIs are driving the data quality projects in your organization. They will only care if the KQIs help to resolve their issues. Also, KQIs may be used to show them progress in your data quality programs. When you complete a project and are able to turn a yellow (cautionary) indicator to green (good), they will understand how the project affected their work.

Delphine’s approach begins by asking business leads and other data users a simple question, “How should we measure data quality.” She gathers feedback via surveys from her business customers and measures progress through response trending over time. Sounds like internal Marketing, right? Delphine also presented a methodology for measuring direct vs. indirect cost savings from Data Quality initiatives. She has clearly spent a lot of time working on this approach and is doing a great job. I really enjoyed this presentation.

She also recommended involving the end users early on to define:

• What are the Key Quality Indicators (KQIs) that are important to the business?
• Should the KQIs be global or local?
• What is the cost of poor quality data?
• Are the KQI’s different by country?

I love these questions. Simple, direct, and open. Rather than telling our peers how we should be measured, ask them and include them in the KQI process.

Demographic vs. Firmagraphic Appends

Note: This is a continuation of the B2B vs. B2C series. I will also be presenting some related material at the MIT Information Quality Symposium next week (MITIQS 7/15-7/17 2009). If you are attending, please introduce yourself.

Data Acquisition is an important part of any data driven Sales and Marketing program. I associate the append process with Marketing since that’s where these programs are generally funded, but the clear beneficiary of the work is the Sales organization. And of course, it takes a partnership between Technology, Sales and Marketing to make data acquisition programs successful. A data file on a shared drive or standalone table in a database has little or no value. The data has to be integrated with customer and prospect lists and loaded into the CRM and SFA systems and / or presented through your BI/DW tools to show ROI. Sorry… I got on a roll with the acronyms. They’re defined at the bottom. I’m in a Data Governance role now. Acronyms and definitions are my life (in a scary, scary way).

This raises the topics of Data Cleansing, Address Standardization, Merging & Matching, Deduplication, Archiving, etc. I’ll save those topics for future posts, but would encourage questions in the comments section. It’s fair to say that without a Data Quality focus you won’t achieve the optimal results for either Demographic or Firmagraphic Data Acquisition program.

Demographic Appends

Demographic data is generally used by Marketers and Analysts to determine the best way to target a consumer base. Starting with a universe of customers or prospects, a company can buy information on:

• Credit History
• Purchasing Patterns
• Housing Location and Situation, e.g. owner, renter
• Salary
• Lifestyle / Family

You can also buy data that segments customers based on the provider’s best information. Some is based on geographic of financial information. Others are based in buying patterns. Sometimes they even have cool segment titles like “Boomer Barons,” “True Blues,” and “Jumbo Families.” (All of those are from the Acxiom Personicx family of pre-defined segments). The goal of a demographic append is really bulk segmentation. How do I get enough information about my consumers to segment them for marketing and analysis. In most cases, the purchaser doesn’t care about any single individual or household, other than to get them into the correct program. The marketers are looking at sets of consumers, and then targeting from there.

In very high end consumer sales, e.g., luxury items, high net worth banking etc, you may find cases where sales people will use the appended data at the individual level. But generally it’s used for grouping customers into buckets, finding buying patterns and trends across like customers, and performing analyses such as next best product, lifetime value, and similar. Consumer sales is so transactional, that there isn’t time to research before any one conversation.

Firmagraphic Appends

B2B data, which I prefer to call “Firmagraphic” but have also seen called Firmographic or Firma-graphic, can provide value for not only segmentation, but also for pre-call research. B2B Sales is moving toward a more consultative approach where the sales rep becomes more of a partner with the purchaser. The best sales reps do this across all businesses. Rather than try to sell one product or service (transactional), the sales rep tries to understand the company’s need and deliver a suite of prodcuts & services and sometimes even the workers to use them (in an outsourcing arrangement). I’m sure if you’re reading this you’ve seen the varying styles of transactional and consultative sales reps.

To arm those consultative sales reps with the appropriate information, companies often purchase firmagraphic data and load it into their CRM systems. This data may be grouped into:

• Parent Child Relationships
• Locations of Related Companies
• Contact Information for Executives
• Industry Codes
• Number of Employees
• Revenue

This allows the rep to quickly look at the companie’s situation, and taylor their initial pitch accordingly. “I see you’re in a fast moving industry, with over 100 employees, and that you’re company has decentralized offices across the country. Have you heard of Product A that might meet your needs?” That conversation can only happen to a perspective customer if a firmagraphic append has happened previously. Which reminds me that another form of firmagraphic purchase is the ubiquitous, “Get 200 leads in your target industry,” but that’s not what I’m talking about here.

Segmentation of B2B customers is also sometimes based on Firmagraphic appends,  but as mentioned in the original B2B vs. B2C post, householding in B2B is focused on creating parent child relationships among your customers and prospects. You should also use all of your existing customer information including location, purchasing and servicing history, and past communication response to segment your customers. Once you have those relationships built, you can begin to analyze your coverage of headquarters and branches based on firmagraphic data.

Analytics then focuses on similar models for next best product, lifetime value, likelihood to purchase, likelihood to respond to certain campaigns and others. The tools to d

Acronym Glossary

CRM: Customer Relationship Management. Generally refers to the systems used by Sales and Marketing teams to store and organize customer contact information, purchasing, and servicing history. CRM systems also pump out lots of data used for operational reporting and as inputs to customer analysis and segmentation.

SFA: Sales Force Automation. Tools used by Sales Reps to manage their actitivities. This would include follow ups/reminders, appointments, leads, renewals, etc.  SFA systemsalso includes the operational reporting of those activities in some cases.

BI: Business Intelligence. The analytics and reporting tools built on top of the Data Warehouse. Business Intelligence can also be used to describe the practice of analyzing data to determine important insights and drive strategy. These tools look across CRM, SFA, manufacturing and financial systems.

B2B: Business to Business. Marketing and Sales activities along with associated products and services targeted at business customers.

B2C: Business to Consumer. Marketing and Sales activities along with associated products and services targeted at individuals or households of consumers.

ROI: Return on Investment. A simple calcualtion that takes the difference between the cost of a program and the returned value from it, and divides it by the cost of the program. So if I spend $100 and make $150, my ROI would be the $50 of benefit over the $100 of cost: .5 ROI. People often forget to subtract the cost from the numerator and inflate their ROIs.